You’ve probably seen that cartoon where someone asks a crowd, “Who wants change?” and every hand goes up.
Then they ask, “Who wants TO change?” and not a single hand moves.
It’s funny because it’s painfully true. And nowhere more so than in a team where negativity has taken hold. Everyone wants things to be different. Far fewer people stop to ask what they could do differently themselves.
There’s a quote often attributed to Elizabeth Gilbert that I love: “I don’t know a single life transformation that didn’t begin with the person in question getting tired of their own bullshit.”
I think there’s a lot of truth in that.
Sometimes we complain about something for so long that we eventually bore ourselves into doing something about it. We reach that point where we say, “Nope. Enough. I’m done.”
And suddenly, seemingly overnight (although it’s usually been months or years in the making), we make a different choice. We deal with the shoulder ache. End the relationship. Move jobs. Or simply, change our attitude.
How one negative team member affects the whole team
I’ve recently been working with a team where the dynamics have become rather depressing. People are exhausted, and it’s not the usual kind of exhaustion that comes from too much work or constant organisational change.
There’s a long-standing pattern of frustration, complaining and negativity, driven largely by one particularly influential individual. Some of the frustrations are entirely legitimate. Things haven’t been dealt with properly, and there’s good reason to be unhappy.
But the way those frustrations are being expressed is having an enormous impact on everyone else.
People have started keeping their heads down, withdrawing from conversations and doing what they need to do to protect themselves. The energy has drained out of the team.
And here’s the thing. This individual has enormous influence. She’s someone who could really drive positive change if she chose to channel that energy differently.
Three choices when a situation isn’t working
When we’re unhappy with a situation, we generally have three choices. We can try to influence it, doing what we can to actively drive change. We can accept it, genuinely letting go of what we can’t control. Or we can leave it, choosing to go elsewhere.
What doesn’t help is staying exactly where we are, complaining endlessly and expecting something to change.
What the rest of the team can do
But there’s another part to this story.
While leaders have a responsibility to address behaviour that’s damaging the team, what about everyone else? The people who are withdrawing, keeping their heads down or occasionally joining in the complaining?
They have choices too.
A few years ago, I met a friend for an early morning run. When I arrived, she’d invited another woman along. No problem, the more the merrier.
Except this woman decided our run was the perfect opportunity to offload every frustration in her life onto a complete stranger. Her relationship, other people, everything that was wrong in her world. It was relentless.
I could literally feel my energy draining. My steps got heavier. My lovely morning mood disappeared.
Eventually, we reached a corner and I simply said, “I’m going to turn around here. Cheers, guys!”
And off I went, enjoying the rest of my run on my own.
Later, I messaged my friend and explained that I work hard to start my days positively, and that kind of energy wasn’t what I wanted to choose at 5am.
It was a small choice. But it was mine to make.
What choosing differently sounds like in a team
We have more influence over the environments we participate in than we give ourselves credit for.
In a team, that might sound like:
“I’ve decided I want to bring a more constructive mindset into this week.”
“I don’t really want to get involved in conversations about people who aren’t here.”
“Have you spoken to her directly about this?”
“I understand you’re frustrated. What do you think we could actually do about it?”
None of these requires someone else’s permission.
And imagine what might shift if several people started making these small choices consistently. If, instead of joining in the gossip, people redirected the conversation. If they stopped reinforcing the very patterns they were so unhappy about.
Over time, that’s how a team starts to establish its own standards for what’s acceptable. By paying as much attention to how they work together as what they deliver.
Self-leadership: not waiting for someone else to go first
This is self-leadership in practice. Recognising where we have influence and taking responsibility for how we show up, even when other people aren’t doing the same.
For leaders, dealing with a negative team member starts with separating the frustration from the way it’s being expressed. The frustrations may be legitimate and worth acting on. The complaining, gossip and drain on everyone else are not. Name that impact directly, and invite them to use their influence to drive the change they want to see. Then name the shared part with your team: addressing damaging behaviour is your job, but setting the standard for how the team responds to it is something everyone can own.
Of course, individual choices won’t always be enough to shift a dysfunctional team or organisation. Sometimes the bigger system needs to change, and sometimes we need to recognise when it’s time to leave.
But imagine if we all stopped waiting for someone else to go first.
If we got tired enough of our own bullshit to start making the changes we keep wishing other people would make.
What’s one thing you’re tired of complaining about that you could start doing differently yourself?
If the same frustrations keep landing back on your desk, it may be a pattern rather than a one-off. Read more about why teams get stuck in the same patterns, or take the free 4-minute Team Dynamics Diagnostic to see what might be going on beneath the surface.